Untangling the Future: Robotic Hair Brushing and Detangling

In recent years, the realm of “soft robotics” has burgeoned, propelling advancements in the design, control, and creation of robots with softer structures and systems (think cuddly toy robot that can safely interact with humans). This domain of engineering is also helping us to understand interactions of robots with complex, soft objects and environments containing living things, through enhanced modeling techniques. Such research widens the spectrum of materials and environments where robotic operations are possible, enabling robots to tackle the same kind of intricate tasks effortlessly executed by humans. A prime example of this application lies in assistance and care robots. The global uptick in population, extended life expectancy, and escalating demands on healthcare systems increase the potential humanitarian impact of employing robots in personal care and assistance for the elderly and the less able.

With the amalgamation of soft robotic technologies, machine learning, and modelling of soft organic materials, the feasibility of crafting robots for care and healthcare applications has been on an upward trajectory for the last 10 years. However until quite recently, a task that has garnered scant attention within this realm is hair-brushing and combing. While hair brushing is seemingly quite a mundane task for humans, it demands a nuanced understanding of the interaction between deformable brush bristles or comb teeth and soft hair fibers, necessitating both visual and tactile feedback and adjustment of force, speed, brush stroke length, as well the position and angle of the brush for different areas of the scalp.

Care needs to be taken not to put too much strain on the hair, to avoid pain and to prevent hair breakage. How different people brush and comb their hair changes depending on how curly their hair is, how long it is, and how tangled it may be. Brushing and combing techniques change again depending on whether the hair is wet or dry. How often someone uses shampoo and/or conditioner, and even air humidity also has an impact on how best to brush hair. Inevitably, hair brushing and combing is a predominantly self-care task, but it becomes a significant challenge for the elderly, the very young, or those with physical limitations who are less able to hold and adjust a brush, or to see their hair as it is being brushed.

Assistance in hair brushing and combing has been shown to be beneficial for both mental health and the physical scalp condition of individuals less able to maintain their own hair. For now at least, assistance with hair brushing and combing is given by personal care assistants and/or other family members. However, in the personal care robot sector, recent strides have been made including the development of robotic systems for hair washing, shaving, as well as for make-up assistance. The burgeoning interest in robotic care-givers or robots supporting human care assistance underscores the potential of extending robotic task-solving capacities to complex tasks like hair brushing. This not only calls for innovative safe hardware, but also a much deeper grasp of the complex behavior of soft hair and tangled fibers.

Recent studies have presented experimental models for combing entangled hairs using a “visuo-motor” feedback loop that would help a robot adjust its hair brushing technique. The models shed light on the dynamics of hair combing concerning the number of entanglements a robot may have to deal with, and how efficacious and efficient brushing can be achieved by the robot selecting appropriate brushing lengths and brushing height for different hair types (straight or curly), with computer vision deployed to ascertain the curliness of hair. The model systems have led to the development of a computer algorithm driven approach for brushing various hair types.

A robot with a soft brush and sensors has been built to test these computer model systems and has done well in initial tests. In a publication from 2021 the robot hair brush was experimentally validated using wigs of different lengths and curliness and compared to human brushing techniques. However, while this study demonstrated effective hair-brushing using a robot, the avenue for further improvement is vast – the hair brushing robot is still pretty basic and has limited flexibility right now. Future work to develop hair brushing robots will need to encompass more realistic experiments with humans to garner subjective feedback from the subjects. Pain is a multifaceted phenomenon, and the avoidance of it necessitates human trials to genuinely comprehend the robot’s performance and to adjust its activities to avoid pain.

Interestingly, the models of entwined soft hairs that have been utilized for developing hair brushing robots holds promise for broader applications. For instance, it could bolster the development of robotic techniques for managing ropes, fibrous systems, or even robots adept at manipulating spaghetti. The exploration of robotic hair brushing not only unveils a pathway for alleviating daily challenges for specific human populations, but it also sets a precedent for further innovative applications of soft robotics in personal care and beyond.

In conclusion, the pioneering journey into robotic hair brushing and detangling illuminates the remarkable potential of soft robotics in transcending the traditional boundaries of robotic capabilities. The synthesis of soft robotic technologies, machine learning, and intricate modeling of soft materials has not only made strides in addressing the nuanced challenges of hair care, but has also heralded a broader spectrum of applications awaiting exploration. The evolving models and algorithms, backed by experimentation, are pivotal in refining the design and operation of personal care robots. These advancements indicate a promising future where robots could seamlessly integrate into our daily care routines, offering invaluable assistance especially to those who need it most. The venture of robotic hair combing is a testament to the possibilities that lie within the realm of soft robotics, and invite further exploration and innovation in this interdisciplinary domain.

Bibliography

1.
Rosenblum RE, Carlson WE, Tripp E. Simulating the structure and dynamics of human hair: Modelling, rendering and animation. J Visual Comput Animat. 1991;2(4):141–8.
1.
Akkermans RLC, Warren PB. Multiscale modelling of human hair. Al–Ghoul M, Boon JP, Coveney PV, editors. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences. 2004 Aug 15;362(1821):1783–93.
1.
Lura DJ, Carey SL, Dubey RV. Study of variation in human upper body parameters and motion for use in robotics based simulation. Annu Int Conf IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc. 2013;2013:6937–40.
1.
Yu Y, Yang W, Wang B, Meyers MA. Structure and mechanical behavior of human hair. Materials Science and Engineering: C. 2017 Apr 1;73:152–63.
1.
Plumb-Reyes TB. Some Topics in Topological Mechanics [PhD thesis]. [Cambridge, Massachusetts]: Harvard University; 2021.
1.
Hughes J, Plumb-Reyes T, Charles N, Mahadevan L, Rus D. Detangling hair using feedback-driven robotic brushing. In: 2021 IEEE 4th International Conference on Soft Robotics (RoboSoft). 2021. p. 487–94.
1.
Bilyea AJ, French SH, Abdullah HA. Modeling contact forces during human-robot interactions for performing activities of daily living. Proc Inst Mech Eng H. 2023 Jul;237(7):829–40.